Okay, the title is pretty self-explanatory. This is MY list. You may agree with some of my choices here…or not…but it’s subjective. What we can ALL agree on is these were fun when we were kids, and still are!
A couple of caveats before we begin…this list is gonna be heavy with Rankin/Bass stuff. No way around it. Also, the word “classic” is flexible and is not used only in the context of age. Many factors make something “classic”, and in the case of these animated specials, things like music, voice cast, and animation style all play a part.
And here we go…
#10 – Nestor The Long-Eared Christmas Donkey (1977)
Produced by Rankin/Bass, it basically tells the same story as Rudolph: “Misfit shunned due to perceived deformity is later seen as special and appreciated”.
The voice cast is pretty darn good, with Roger Miller as narrator, Brenda Vacarro, Rankin/Bass staple Paul Frees, and the legendary Don Messick.
#9 – Rudolph’s Shiny New Year (1976)
A sequel to the original Rudolph tale, here again, a perceived deformity is the main plot point. Happy, The Baby New Year has some big-ass ears, and runs away because people laugh when they see them. Father Time (Red Skelton) tasks Rudolph with finding Happy and bringing him back so the New Year can begin. Along the way, Rudolph meets some new friends that aid him on his adventure. Featuring an awesome voice cast, including Billie Mae Richards back as Rudolph, and great performances by Morey Amsterdam, Frank Gorshin, Paul Frees and Don Messick.
#8 – A Wish For Wings That Work (1991)
Okay, our first non Rankin/Bass entry and the only entry not from the 60’s or 70’s. First of all, I LOVED Bloom County growing up, so when Opus the Penguin, Bill The Cat, and friends finally made it to the small screen, it was a lock that I was gonna dig it. Creator Berke Breathed crafted a lovely story about Opus dealing with his inability to fly and thinking himself useless, until he helps Santa on Christmas Eve. Great voice work from the stellar friggin’ cast of Michael Bell, Frank Welker, Tress MacNeille, John Byner, Joe Alaskey and Dustin Hoffman and Robin Williams. Yes, you read that right.
#7 – The Year Without a Santa Claus (1974)
Rankin/Bass at it again! Convinced nobody cares about Christmas anymore, Santa stays in bed and sends his elves out to find people who believe. While on their elfin adventure, they encounter Heat Miser and Cold Miser, brothers who are always at war with one another. Mrs Claus convinces them to stop fighting and work together to help people believe again, which gets Santa up off his jolly ass and back to work. This is considered a sequel to the earlier “Santa Claus is Coming To Town”, and features Mickey Rooney back as Kris Kringle. Other voice duties are wonderfully handled by Shirley Booth, Dick Shawn, George S. Irving, and Bob McFadden. Oh, and as much as you try, you cannot shake the ear candy of The Heat Miser/Cold Miser song out of your damn head.
#6 – ‘Twas the Night Before Christmas (1974)
No puppets here, so it can’t be Rankin/Bass, right? WRONG! The story tells of a young mouse who sends a letter to Santa saying the town does not believe anymore. To convince Santa that they do, a local clockmaker makes a beautiful clock that plays a song that will hopefully appease Santa. Narrated by George Gobel and featuring the talents of Joel Grey, Tammy Grimes and Bob McFadden, it’s a cute twist on the Christmas classic. And the songs also stay with you for days.
#5 – Santa Claus Is Coming To Town (1970)
You all know the song, and dammit, if there’s a song about something Christmas-y, then Rankin and Bass are gonna make a special about it! Mickey Rooney stars as Santa, as we find out exactly how he came to be the bringer of toys. The ruler of Sombertown, Burgermeister Meisterburger, outlaws all toys. Santa finds clever ways to bring the toys to the children, and along the way, we learn why he grew a beard, wears a red suit, goes down chimneys, and other Santa-y things. Narrated by Fred Astaire, the cast is rounded out by Keenan Wynn, Joan Gardner, Robie Lester, and Rankin/Bass regular, Paul Frees.
#4 – A Charlie Brown Christmas (1965)
You knew this was gonna be near the top of the list. Perpetual loser Charlie Brown feels lost as commercialism takes over the holidays, and he loses sight of the true meaning of Christmas. Through several vignettes of him interacting with his peers, rescuing an anemic tree, and Linus reading from the Gospel of Luke, he regains some holiday spirit. The story is charming, Vince Guaraldi’s music is timeless, and even though I’m not religious, I still get a kick out of Linus dropping the Holy truth on everyone…Kinda like Sam Jackson in Pulp Fiction….okay, maybe not. As for the voice cast, Peter Robbins played Charlie Brown in this and “It’s The Great Pumpkin, Charlie Brown”, but all Peanuts characters were replaced as their voices changed…kinda like Menudo.
#3 – Frosty The Snowman (1968)
This was the first Rankin/Bass holiday special to pitch the puppets and go for a classic animation style. If you know the song, you basically know the story. Frosty comes to life thanks to the discarded hat of mediocre magician Professor Hinkle. When Hinkle realizes that the hat is actually magical, he tries to get it back. To escape Hinkle, Frosty and his young friend Karen make their way to the North Pole, and get a little help from a certain Kris Kringle. There’s a reason that this is in the top three. The animation is gorgeous, the song, already a classic, brings a smile to your face, and the voice work is outstanding! Narrated by Jimmy Durante, who also delivers a great version of the title song, the cast also includes Jackie Vernon as Frosty, Billy De Wolfe, Paul Frees, and the First Lady of Voiceovers, June Foray, as Karen. (However, in later editions, June’s parts were edited out and replaced with an uncredited voice, with the exception of the songs) Not a damn thing wrong with this on any level.
#2 – Dr. Seuss’ How The Grinch Stole Christmas (1966)
What can I say? Chuck Jones’ animation is without peer. The classic Dr. Seuss tale is superbly narrated by Boris Karloff. A synopsis seems unnecessary, as if you have never seen it, your childhood was incomplete. Little known fact: the song, “You’re a Mean One, Mr. Grinch” was not sung by Karloff, but by Thurl Ravenscroft, who you might know as the voice of Tony the Tiger (They’re Greaaat!) of Frosted Flakes fame. Also, little Cindy-Lou Who was voiced by the incomparable June Foray.
#1 – Rudolph The Red-Nosed Reindeer (1964)
The one that started it all! This Rankin/Bass classic holds up after 59 years. Again, a synopsis seems redundant. Suffice to say that a brilliant story, characterizations, toe- tapping songs, and our first exposure to classic stop-animation all come together in a perfect-storm of holiday brilliance! Narrated by Burl Ives, who also sings the title song, Canadian voice talents also abound, as Billie Mae Richards voices Rudolph (she thinks I’m cuuuuuuute!). She is joined by Larry D. Mann, Paul Soles, and Paul Kligman, who is also remembered as the voice of J. Jonah Jameson in the 1967 Spider-Man cartoon. Just a stellar production from start to finish, and if it taught us anything, it’s that Bumbles bounce!
So there’s my list. Let me know if you agree with my choices, and throw out any of your favourites that I might have overlooked. With the holiday season upon us, I encourage you to grab your family, sit in front of the boob-tube, and watch as many of these treasured Christmas classics as possible.
Merry Christmas!
Garnet
Posted in
Voiceovers and Stuff and tagged
animation,
Billie Mae Richards,
Burl Ives,
Charlie Brown,
Christmas,
Frank Welker,
Frosty,
Grinch,
Michael Bell,
Paul Frees,
Paul Soles,
Rankin/Bass,
Rudolph,
Santa,
voiceovers